Food Items that You Can Make in Your Toaster Oven

If you have been using a toaster oven, then you know how useful it can be. When it comes to preparing breakfast, this kitchen appliance can work as a glorious savior. Although they are best known for warming snacks, toaster ovens are basically countertop mini ovens. These ovens are capable of preheating faster than the larger ones, without making the kitchen very hot. Moreover, some advanced models can air-fry your food. 

What can you cook in a toaster oven

If you are wondering what can you make in a toaster oven, rest easy. You can bake pizzas, roast veggies, prepare meats and sausages in it. And trust us. Among all the toaster oven recipes, baking cookies are possible as well. Furthermore, it is a reasonable alternative to baking a whole-size batch. 

However, you must keep it in mind that like other kitchen appliances, a toaster oven has limitations. For instance, a microwave oven is best if you want to have piping hot food quickly. So is an instant pot in case you want to speed up your cooking time. 

Nevertheless, a toaster oven will serve you right if you know how to use it and get familiar with the toaster oven meals. That’s why we have created this easy to follow guide on the food items that you can make in your toaster oven. 

Things to make in a toaster oven

Before we dive into the list of food items that you can make in this oven, let’s take a quick look at the essential foods first. In addition to breakfast sandwiches, bagels, and toast, a toaster oven is generally used for warming frozen snacks. You can easily warm frozen pizza, chicken nuggets, spring rolls, even mozzarella sticks.

Now let’s take a look at the food items that often get overlooked while using a toaster oven.




You can roast your veggies in your toaster oven and within a short time. Some toaster oven comes with extra accessories like roasting pan, broiling rack, pizza pan, etc. All you have to do is put your veggies on the pan and roast them before serving. Models like Breville Oven Air also includes a mesh basket rack for air frying.



Baked potatoes

You can bake potatoes in your toaster oven without much trouble. Just preheat to 400 degrees Fahrenheit while you wash and brush the potatoes(two large russet potatoes for this recipe). Then give them a gentle coating of olive oil, and sprinkle some salt and black pepper. After that poke them with a knife on both sides and roast them for 50 minutes. 

After it’s done, remove them and cut them open. Give the insides a fluff. You can add a pat of butter and garnish them with shredded cheddar if you like. With this recipe, the potatoes will be crispy while having a light, creamy texture inside.




Whenever you feel like having a brat, use your toaster oven without any hesitation. You don’t have to boil them. Just throw them in the roasting pan after preheating the oven to 400 degrees Fahrenheit. We recommend you roast for 5 to 10 minutes(depending on how you like them). 

However, be cautious while cooking these as they tend to release juice while heating up. So, in case there is smoke or fire, shut the oven off.

Cookies and sweet treats

Cookies and sweet treats

Cookies and sweet treats

A toaster oven is a great appliance to bake small batches of brownies, cookies, and other treats as such. Moreover, cleaning it up will be faster than your large-size appliance, and no extra sweet treats will sit on the counter to taunt you.

Nevertheless, while it comes to using your toaster oven for baking, you must be mindful of these three things. 

  • Notice the packaging of parchment paper(that is used for baking cookies). You’ll see that it says not to use it in a toaster oven. The reason for this is that if the paper comes in contact with the heating elements, fire can ignite. Therefore, be mindful of the risk in case you want to use parchment paper for baking in your toaster oven. 

  • Be careful while using glass dishes in the toaster oven. Some glass dishes like Pyrex must not be used in the toaster oven. The website of Pyrex points this out as well. Hence, use a metal pan while baking brownies or cake in your toaster oven.

  • Remember that baking requires precise temperatures than roasting. Therefore, it’s better if you check that your toaster oven is getting to the right temperature or not. To do so, you can use an oven thermometer while baking a batch of cookies.